Thursday, July 5, 2012

ECB rate cut impact will be marginal at best

The markets were not impressed by today's policy announcement from the ECB. Sovereign spreads are wider, the euro is lower by 1.1%, and European stocks are down 1.2% on the day. Here is what the ECB's Governing Council had decided:

ECB:
1. The interest rate on the main refinancing operations [MRO] of the Eurosystem will be decreased by 25 basis points to 0.75%, starting from the operation to be settled on 11 July 2012.

2. The interest rate on the marginal lending facility will be decreased by 25 basis points to 1.50%, with effect from 11 July 2012.

3. The interest rate on the deposit facility will be decreased by 25 basis points to 0.00%, with effect from 11 July 2012.
What does this mean for financial institutions and the ECB's attampt to ease credit conditions across the Eurozone?

1. About €180bn is currently borrowed under the MRO, and the rate cut should provide some relief for periphery banks who are the primary users of the facility. But the cut translates into savings of about €37.5 million euros a month - for all the banks using the facility combined. This is clearly helpful but is going to make little difference in these banks' behavior (in terms of credit) because they are looking for liquidity relief, not a tiny reduction in their borrowing costs.

2. Only €0.7bn is borrowed under the marginal lending facility. That's less than €150 thousand a month in savings - not even worth discussing.

3. Setting the deposit rate to zero (something the Fed had also considered) will have an impact on German and other stronger Eurozone institutions who have a great deal of excess liquidity. Thus far these banks have been moving funds between the reserve accounts and the deposit facility. That's because they need to maintain a minimum average balance in the reserve account (which pays zero interest on excess reserves). Once they achieve that average for the month (by holding an excess amount over a few days) they would move the funds back into the deposit facility which paid them 25bp.

ECB Deposit Facility (€MM)

Now with the reserve account and the Deposit Facility both paying zero on excess reserves, they will simply leave the money in the reserve account. Other than this change, banks' behavior is not driven by what they receive on excess reserves and whether the reserves sit in the Deposit Facility or the reserve account. It is highly unlikely therefore that the difference between 25bp and zero on deposits at the ECB will somehow encourage these stronger banks to extend more credit.

The markets were hoping for more action from the ECB on the heels of the recent summit. The hope was that if the politicians make a move in the "right direction", the ECB will reward them with more "non-standard monetary policy measures". But Draghi thought otherwise and of course the markets reacted accordingly.


For further discussion on the ECB rate cut see this post by Kostas Kalevras.

SoberLook.com

Recent US government spending cuts dampened recovery - further "austerity" may risk recession

In this week's economic report, the IMF described the US recovery as tepid and highly vulnerable to global shocks. This is nothing particularly surprising, but the report discusses in some detail sources of risk to the economy.
IMF: - The U.S. recovery remains tepid. After rebounding in the second half of 2011, growth slowed to around 2 percent in the first half of this year. Strong headwinds persist on private consumption, as households continue to deleverage.
...
The United States remains vulnerable to contagion from an intensification of the euro area debt crisis. U.S. financial institutions have limited direct claims on the euro area periphery, but strong financial linkages with the core euro area. Financial stresses in the region may affect the United States mainly via a generalized increase in risk aversion and lower asset prices (including for U.S. multinational firms with substantial sales in the euro area) even though safe haven flows would likely reduce yields on safe assets, notably U.S. Treasuries. Lower demand in the euro area would reduce U.S. exports to the region, while U.S. dollar appreciation on safe haven flows would hurt exports more generally.
The IMF also pointed to the "fiscal cliff" uncertainty as one of the developments inhibiting growth.
IMF: - It is critical to remove the uncertainty created by the “fiscal cliff” as well as promptly raise the debt ceiling, pursuing a pace of deficit reduction that does not sap the economic recovery.
In fact it is the broader government belt tightening that has already taken place which is contributing to this weakness - even before the impact of the "fiscal cliff". Here is a comparison of the recent government spending growth (inflation adjusted) to the average of the previous 9 cycles. The initial stimulus has ended and cuts are starting to take effect just when historically in the cycle government spending had been picking up.

X-axis in quarters (source: DB)
DB: - Last quarter, inflation-adjusted federal government spending declined -5.9% after falling -7.0% in the previous quarter. These were the two largest back-to-back declines since Q4 1995 and were predominantly the result of sharp falls in military outlays, ostensibly related to the withdrawal of troops in the Middle East. The drop in government spending reduced Q1 GDP by about half of a percentage point.
Unfortunately the US economy is still very much dependent on a steady flow of federal dollars. Any further disruptions in this flow would severely dampen the recovery process. That is why if not managed appropriately, a combination of spending cuts and tax increases of the "fiscal cliff" could easily tip the US economy into a recession.



SoberLook.com

Wednesday, July 4, 2012

ECB's balance sheet hits €3.1 trillion; nearly half the assets are loans to banks

The ECB continues its relentless march of balance sheet expansion. For the first time the total assets of the Eurosystem have exceeded €3.1 trillion.

€ MM

Jean-Claude Trichet used to argue that unlike the Fed's balance sheet during 2008-09 period, the Eurosystem assets were dominated by securities, gold, and foreign reserves, rather than loans to banks. That composition is changing quickly however. Here it the ECB's balance sheet assets breakdown from a year ago - with circled items representing lending to Eurozone's banking institutions under various programs.

 

And here is the current balance sheet asset breakdown. Lending to banks went from under a quarter of the balance sheet to close to half (47%) in a year. Trichet would have a tough time makeing the same statement today.



And this expansion shows no sign of abating as loans to Eurozone's financial institutions continue to grow, rapidly approaching one and a half trillion euros.

€ MM


SoberLook.com

Corn prices break above the 2008 highs

The drought across the US continues to cause havoc, driving agricultural commodities prices higher. Corn futures hit a record today, exceeding the 2008 highs.

Corn futures
Reuters: - The hot, dry weather prompted analysts to reduce corn yield estimates, pointing to a smaller crop in the world's No. 1 grower than had been expected. In a Reuters poll Tuesday - the day after the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) reported on crop conditions - analysts on average pegged the U.S. corn yield at 153.4 bushels per acre, down from 157.3 bushels a week ago.

The USDA on Monday slashed its condition rating for U.S. corn to 48 percent good-to-excellent, down 8 percentage points from a week earlier. It pegged the soybean crop at 45 percent good-to-excellent, compared with 53 percent a week ago.
The forecasters are predicting some relief from the heat wave coming soon, but the damage may already have been done. As the chart below shows, corn crop conditions have deteriorated rapidly in recent weeks and the futures prices are reflecting it.

Corn: percentage of crops in "good" or "excellent" conditions (source: USDA)



SoberLook.com

It may take more than stimulus to arrest Brazil's slowdown

As is the case with China and India, we are now seeing material deterioration in Brazil's business conditions, particularly manufacturing. The June manufacturing PMI is showing some unexpected weakness.

Source: HSBC/Markit
HSBC/Markit: - June data indicated a further deterioration in manufacturing business conditions in Brazil. Both output and new orders fell over the month, with the rates of contraction the strongest in eight months. Manufacturers generally commented on weak client demand. Concurrently, job losses were reported for the third month running...
Today's Industrial Production number came in considerably weaker than expected - down 4.3% YOY vs. 3.3% expected.

Brazil Industrial Production
GS: - The industrial sector has been beset by higher costs (e.g., labor), soft domestic and external demand, and external competitiveness issues related to a still overvalued BRL.
The government has been pushing through quite a bit of stimulus to halt economic contraction.
Reuters: - Intent on reviving growth, President Dilma Rousseff's administration has chopped central bank benchmark interest rates, provided industries and consumers with tax breaks, and vowed to step up government purchases of industrial goods.
In anticipation of further rate cuts, the yields on government bonds have come off sharply. As the chart below shows, the 1-year yield is at a multi-year low.

Brazil 1-year government bond yield
Bloomberg: - The central bank has cut its target lending rate by 4 percentage points since August, the most among Group of 20 nations, to a record low of 8.5 percent. Traders are betting policy makers will reduce the benchmark to 7.75 percent by the end of next month, interest-rate futures yields indicate.
Some analysts are suggesting that if Brazil's currency weakens further (BRL is down 16% from this year's highs), Brazil's manufacturing may regain its competitiveness. But as with other emerging market economies, years of strong growth have covered up some structural problems that may not be simply patched up by lower rates, weaker currency, or other government stimulus.
WSJ: - [Paulo] Leme [chairman of Goldman Sachs in Brazil], said Brazil's problems may go deeper than a sluggish global economy. Poor infrastructure, lagging educational standards and other structural problems held back Latin America's biggest country. "The country has a lot of room to grow...but it needs to resolve its own inefficiencies."


SoberLook.com

Monday, July 2, 2012

Trying to keep deposits in Spain

How does Banco de Sabadell, Spain's 5th largest bank try to keep depositors from moving cash to Germany or Switzerland? They offer up a juicy deposit rate. The bigger the portion of your deposit you are wiling to lock up for a year ("Fund"), the more they will pay.


This is expensive. And some of the smaller banks pay even more. In fact Spain's banks pay more for deposits than they make on mortgages. Why bother when you can replace depositors with the ECB.
Bloomberg: - While Spain’s two largest lenders, Banco Santander SA (SAN) and Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria SA (BBVA), earn most of their income outside the country, smaller banks depend on domestic business. Most are paying higher rates for deposits than they earn on mortgages. Their most profitable trade -- borrowing at 1 percent from the European Central Bank and lending to the Spanish government at 6 percent -- risks bankrupting the country.
While the recapitalization program should help, ultimately the government is crowding out private credit. A banking system that borrows from the ECB and lends to the government can sustain itself for a while but will be of limited value for economic growth.
SoberLook.com

Sunday, July 1, 2012

The US economy's impact on the presidential race - the good, the bad and the ugly

It's "the economy, stupid" were the words used by James Carville, Bill Clinton's campaign strategist. The strategy allowed the Clinton campaign to take advantage of the post-Gulf-War recession to defeat George Bush Sr. The question remains whether the current difficult economic conditions will deliver the same outcome for President Obama.

Here are some interesting data compiled by Barclays Capital that looks at previous incumbent presidents running for their second term. In each case the comparison is made between specific economic indicators during a president's tenure and the votes the incumbent was able to win in the general elections. Let's look at the good, the bad, and the ugly of the US economic indicators during the past 4 years and what those indicators were for the previous incumbents.

1. The good: both US inflation gauge and the change in the unemployment rate will work to President's advantage.


Source: Barclays Capital

2. The bad: consumer sentiment (University of Michigan expectations) and the level of unemployment rate puts Mr. Obama with the losing group of incumbents.




3. The ugly: the average GDP growth makes the past period truly stand out.



Clearly this and other indicators are not necessarily the result of who was in the White House in the past four years (though there is some lively debate about that). But what this tells us is that there is a significant relationship between economic conditions and the incumbent's ability to win the second term.  That's why there is a correlation between the equity markets and Obama's odds on Intrade for example. The state of the economy in the next few months will likely decide the next US president.
Barclays Capital: - Weak GDP growth and high unemployment pose significant headwinds to the current incumbent. To overcome them, history suggests that unemployment would need to keep trending down and sentiment would need to strengthen prior to the election.



SoberLook.com

Global drought is damaging crops; will have a destabilizing geopolitical effect

The recent drought conditions across some of areas in the US have caused a number of wildfires in western states. The media has focused on the fact that some states are cancelling the 4th of July fireworks in fear that they could ignite dry brush and trigger yet another wildfire.

Source: University of Nebraska

But there is another effect the drought is having on many parts of the country - damage to the nation's crops.
Reuters: - Just one year ago Jeff Scates saw the worst flooding on his southern Illinois farmland since 1937. Today, Scates is watching his corn fields shrivel from the driest season in 24 years.

"We've gone from one extreme to the other, from being flooded on three-quarters of the farm now to a drought," said Scates, 42, who with his family members farms 15,000 acres of corn, soybeans and other crops along the Kentucky-Indiana border where the Ohio and Wabash Rivers meet.

Scates said his corn is still in better shape than many fields of his neighbors, who farm sandier soils that do not retain moisture. Moisture is needed to develop a strong root system to sustain plants in the hottest months of July and August.
The percentage of crops in good conditions has declined far below the 5-year range for this time of the year.

Corn crops % in good conditions (source: Credit Suisse)
Soy crops % in good conditions (source: Credit Suisse)
Futures: - The most recent crop progress report released on June 25 is not up to date with the effects of the weather of the past few days. But even so, the downgrade to the crop’s health was steep. The good-to-excellent portion of the crop fell to 56% from 63% the week before. Last year at this time, the good-to-excellent section was 68%. The July 2 progress report will almost certainly contain a further reduction in the estimate for the quality of the crop.
What's particularly troubling is that these drought conditions are not limited to the US.
FT: - Fears of crop damage in Russia due to dry weather supported wheat prices, with US benchmark prices hitting an eight-month high on Friday, shrugging off concerns about the eurozone and global economic growth.

Concerns over the past few weeks about limited rainfall in southern Russia elevated this week as farmers in the region faced the critical flowering stage. Winter wheat goes through the flowering phase in the last one to two weeks of May into early June.
And Ukraine's wheat output is materially lower as well. It is particularly painful for a nation that desperately needs hard currency.

Ukraine's wheat output (1000 MT, source: USDA)

In places such as North Korea, where food shortages are a fact of daily life, the drought may have a severe impact on the population. This is clearly a dangerous development given the nation's history of military threats in times of extreme conditions.
The Telegraph: - North Korean soldiers have been dispatched to water crops that are withering in the worst drought to affect the country in more than a century, with the United Nations warning that yields for staples such as wheat, barley and potatoes will inevitably be affected.
Even Australia is cutting wheat output projections.
Reuters: - Australia slashed its winter wheat production forecast by more than 7 percent, heightening global supply worries and boosting U.S. futures, a day after projections of harsh weather hitting output in top exporters Russia, Europe and the United States.
This confluence of global damage to harvests is driving up prices for agricultural commodities, with corn experiencing the sharpest increase.

Wheat futures
Soy futures
Corn futures

A major geopolitical concern stemming from these trends is food inflation. As discussed before, the Arab Spring had less to do with zeal for freedom/democracy and more to do with rising food prices. Nations whose currencies have weakened recently (Egypt, Iran, Pakistan, etc.) will be particularly vulnerable.

Pakistani Rupee at historical lows (number of rupees per dollar) 

The Telegraph: - Food price inflation is already a headache for policymakers around the globe, faced with the pressures of growing populations, rising urbanisation and changing diets.

That means the latest surge in crop prices state-side, with the US producing more than 40pc of global corn exports, is causing some concern. The dry weather is also affecting the Black Sea producers, as well as those on the North China Plain.

SoberLook.com
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Bookmark this post:
Share on StockTwits
Scoop.it